Cut through supplement marketing hype. Learn which supplements actually work, which don't, and why most people waste money on products they don't need.
The supplement industry generates billions of dollars annually by convincing people that pills and powders are essential for fitness results. Walk into any supplement store and you'll face walls of products promising muscle gain, fat loss, enhanced performance, and better health. But how much of this is real, and how much is marketing?
The honest answer is that most supplements are unnecessary, many don't work as advertised, and a few actually provide meaningful benefits. Separating these categories saves you money and helps you focus on what actually matters for results.
Before discussing supplements, understand their place in the results hierarchy.
Training provides the stimulus for adaptation. No supplement compensates for poor or absent training. The best supplement protocol paired with inadequate training produces nothing.
Nutrition provides the raw materials and energy for adaptation. Protein, calories, micronutrients from food are all more important than any supplement. A perfect supplement stack with poor nutrition produces minimal results.
Sleep and recovery allow adaptation to occur. Supplements cannot override sleep deprivation or inadequate recovery.
Consistency over time produces results. Years of consistent training and nutrition without supplements beats inconsistent training with every supplement available.
Supplements are the smallest lever. They might provide 1 to 5 percent improvement when everything else is optimized. For most people, that optimization hasn't happened, making supplements largely irrelevant to their current progress.
A few supplements have substantial evidence supporting their effectiveness.
Creatine monohydrate is the most researched and proven supplement for muscle and strength. It increases phosphocreatine stores, supporting ATP regeneration during high-intensity exercise. Benefits include increased strength, power output, and muscle mass over time. It's safe, cheap, and effective. Take 3 to 5 grams daily without cycling.
Protein powder is food, not really a supplement. It provides a convenient protein source when whole food is impractical. Whey, casein, and plant-based proteins all work. Use them to hit protein targets, not as magic muscle builders.
Caffeine genuinely enhances performance. It reduces perceived exertion, increases alertness, and may improve strength and endurance. Most people already consume it through coffee. Supplemental caffeine pre-workout provides similar benefits at 3 to 6 mg per kilogram of body weight.
Vitamin D matters if you're deficient, which many people are, especially those in northern climates or who spend little time outdoors. Deficiency impairs muscle function and overall health. Test your levels and supplement if needed.
Omega-3 fatty acids from fish oil support overall health with benefits for inflammation, heart health, and potentially muscle protein synthesis. If you don't eat fatty fish regularly, supplementation makes sense.
These five represent supplements with genuine evidence. Notice how short this list is compared to what supplement stores sell.
Some supplements have moderate or situational evidence.
Beta-alanine may improve high-intensity exercise performance lasting 1 to 4 minutes by buffering acid accumulation. The tingling sensation is harmless. Benefits are modest and specific to certain exercise types.
Citrulline may improve blood flow and exercise performance, though effects are relatively small. It's often included in pre-workout supplements.
Ashwagandha has some evidence for reducing cortisol and potentially improving testosterone and strength gains. Results are inconsistent across studies.
Melatonin helps with sleep timing and jet lag. It's not a sedative but a circadian rhythm regulator. Low doses of 0.5 to 3 mg work better than high doses for most people.
These supplements might provide small benefits for some individuals in some circumstances. They're not essential and shouldn't be priorities.
Many popular supplements lack evidence despite widespread use.
BCAAs are unnecessary if you're eating adequate protein. The supposed benefits come from the leucine content, which you get from any complete protein source. Supplementing BCAAs when protein intake is sufficient provides no additional benefit.
Testosterone boosters using herbs like tribulus or fenugreek don't meaningfully raise testosterone in healthy adults. The small changes sometimes observed don't translate to muscle building benefits.
Fat burners are mostly caffeine with unproven additions. Any effect comes from the caffeine, which you can get cheaper from coffee. Proprietary blends often hide ineffective doses of ingredients.
Glutamine doesn't enhance muscle building in people eating adequate protein. The gut uses most supplemental glutamine before it reaches muscles.
Most "proprietary blends" hide underdosed ingredients behind impressive-sounding labels. If a product doesn't disclose exact amounts of each ingredient, be skeptical.
Understanding marketing tactics helps you resist them.
Before and after photos are easily manipulated through lighting, posing, tanning, water manipulation, and timing. They prove nothing about supplement effectiveness.
Sponsored athletes would look impressive regardless of supplements. They have elite genetics, dedicate their lives to training, and often use performance-enhancing drugs. Their physiques don't result from the supplements they endorse.
Cherry-picked studies get cited while contradicting evidence is ignored. A single positive study doesn't establish effectiveness, especially if multiple other studies show no effect.
Proprietary blend labels hide weak dosing. A product might contain a clinically studied ingredient but at a fraction of the dose used in research.
Testimonials reflect placebo effects, coincidence, or payment. Individual stories don't establish causation or represent typical results.
The supplement industry is minimally regulated. Products don't need to prove effectiveness before sale. Claims can be vague enough to avoid legal issues while implying benefits that don't exist.
Despite general skepticism, supplements have appropriate uses.
Documented deficiencies warrant supplementation. If blood tests show vitamin D deficiency, supplement vitamin D. This is medical treatment, not performance enhancement.
Dietary restrictions may create gaps. Vegans may need B12 supplementation. People who don't eat fish may benefit from omega-3s. Address what your diet lacks.
Convenience sometimes matters. Protein powder after a workout when whole food isn't practical serves a legitimate purpose.
After optimizing everything else, small edges may matter. Elite athletes who have maximized training, nutrition, and recovery might benefit from supplements that provide marginal improvements.
For most recreational exercisers, none of these situations require extensive supplementation. The fundamentals haven't been optimized enough for supplements to matter.
If you choose to use supplements, approach them rationally.
Research ingredients independently. Look for peer-reviewed research, not supplement company marketing. Examine what studies actually show, including effect sizes and study quality.
Check for third-party testing. Organizations like NSF Certified for Sport or Informed Sport verify that products contain what labels claim. This matters for avoiding contamination and ensuring accurate dosing.
Start with the proven basics. Creatine and protein powder cover most legitimate needs. Add other supplements only if specific circumstances warrant them.
Track results objectively. If you start a supplement, measure relevant outcomes before and during use. Feeling like something works isn't evidence that it does.
Calculate cost-effectiveness. A supplement providing 2 percent improvement isn't worth significant expense when that money could buy better food or gym access.
Smart purchasing reduces unnecessary spending.
Generic creatine monohydrate works identically to expensive branded versions. Pay for the ingredient, not the marketing.
Bulk protein powder without special formulations costs far less per serving. Basic whey concentrate works fine for most purposes.
Avoid supplement stacks and pre-made combinations. These charge premium prices for convenience while often underdosing key ingredients.
Consider whether you need supplements at all. Most people would see better returns investing that money in quality food, gym memberships, or coaching.
Most supplements are unnecessary. A few, including creatine, protein powder, caffeine, vitamin D if deficient, and omega-3s, have evidence supporting their use. Many popular supplements don't work as advertised.
Supplements occupy the smallest rung on the results hierarchy. Training, nutrition, sleep, and consistency matter far more. Focusing on supplements before optimizing these fundamentals wastes money and attention.
If you use supplements, research independently, verify quality through third-party testing, and track results objectively. Approach the industry with healthy skepticism given its financial incentives to overstate benefits.
Don't waste money on supplements you don't need. The YBW course teaches you what actually matters for results and where supplements fit in the big picture.
Keep Learning
Discover what's really in pre-workout supplements and whether they're worth the money. Learn about effective alternatives that cost far less.
Understand protein powder: different types, when timing matters, and whether you actually need it. Learn to use protein supplements wisely.
Everything you need to know about creatine: how it works, proven benefits, proper dosing, and debunking common myths about safety and side effects.